Reynolds Vapor faces $14.05 million in patent-infringement damages

2022-10-02 06:34:46 By : Mr. ydel ydel

Get the latest local business news delivered FREE to your inbox weekly.

Two Reynolds American Inc. business units face a combined $14.05 million in damages from of a federal jury verdict in a patent-infringement lawsuit involving Reynolds’ top-selling electronic cigarette Vuse.

The initial damages were $10.9 million and later expanded by another $3.16 million .

The jury verdict was rendered Wednesday in the Eastern District Court of Virginia. The lawsuit, filed in April 2020, went to the jury June 8.

Philip Morris Products SA is an affiliate of Philip Morris International Inc., commonly identified corporately as PMI.

The lawsuit involves PMI’s accusations of R.J. Reynolds Vapor Co. infringement involving its Vuse Alto and Vuse Solo e-cigarette products. The other defendant is RAI Strategic Holding Inc.

The PMI U.S. electronic-cigarette patents are: a compact heater designed to increase vaporization efficiency; and a leakage preventer for the liquid used in e-cigarettes.

The jury reviewed six primary claims and 14 dependent claims.

For Vuse Alto, the jury determined Reynolds infringed on one independent and one dependent claim for the compact heater. The jury approved $8 million in damages for those infringements.

For Vuse Solo G2 product, the jury determined Reynolds infringed on one independent and two dependent claims for the leakage preventer.

However, the jury determined Reynolds did not infringe on two sets on one independent and three dependent claims for Vuse Alto involving the leakage preventer.

The jury found that Reynolds did not prove “by clear and convincing evidence” that the Philip Morris leakage preventer patent claims were “invalid as obvious.”

The jury awarded $2.76 million in damages for the leakage preventer patient infringements.

Reynolds said in a statement that “we are pleased that the jury found that Vuse Alto does not infringe” the leakage preventer patent.

“We are disappointed, however, by the jury findings that the same patent was infringed by Vuse Solo and that the (compact heater) was infringed by Vuse Alto.

“We intend to vigorously defend the issues remaining before the court, and, as necessary, appeal the decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit for further review.

PMI said in a statement the jury’s findings of patent infringement “is yet another demonstration of PMI’s position as the clear innovation leader in new technologies that can help smokers switch to better alternatives.”

“This ruling rejects an attempt by BAT to free-ride on our hard work and investment.”

The federal lawsuit in Virginia is one of at least three patent lawsuits involving British American Tobacco Plc/Reynolds and PMI/Altria Group Inc.

In September, the U.S. International Trade Commission issued a final determination of a violation of the Tariff Act of 1930 by Philip Morris USA Inc. and Altria Client Services LLC as it related to two BAT product patents.

The complaint, filed in April 2020, focuses on three heat-not-burn technology patents held by BAT. The patents were issued by the U.S. Patent and Trademark office between November 2012 and December 2019.

An additional two patents are involved in a separate legal proceeding before the patent and trademark office.

As a result, PM USA has been barred from importing PMI’s IQOS 2.4, IQOS 3, IQOS 3 Duo heat-not-burn traditional cigarette products, as well as ordered to halt future sales of those products — marketed as Marlboro HeatSticks — already in the U.S.

In May 2020, Altria filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court for the Middle District of N.C. that alleges Reynolds Vapor is infringing on nine patents with its Vuse electronic cigarette and Velo nicotine smokeless products.

Get the latest local business news delivered FREE to your inbox weekly.

Email notifications are only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching items.

TW Garner Foods Co. showed off Tuesday a $20 million investment that not only represents a new distribution and warehouse center, but also dee…

It was the site of a controversial nursing-home facility closed in June 2015 by state health inspectors after finding multiple rule violations that included a “love nest” in the woods.

A Kernersville couple has paid $809,000 to purchase a restaurant site in Kernersville, according to a Forsyth County Register of Deeds filing …

The subdivision will feature 28 home sites ranging from one to five acres and offer the option of turn-key homes and customized construction within the community’s architectural guidelines.

British American Tobacco is expanding its fledgling presence in the cannabis industry by acquiring a minority stake in Sanity Group Gmbh. BAT …

Wells Fargo & Co. has listed 13 branches nationwide, though none in North Carolina, in its latest closings report to its federal regulator…

Wake Forest University School of Business announced Tuesday the appointment and expanded responsibilities of four associate and assistant deans.

A San Diego group has paid $2.85 million for an industrial warehouse property in Winston-Salem, according to a Forsyth County Register of Deed…

An Ashley Furniture Industries Inc. production decision will increase the workforce at its massive manufacturing, distribution and fulfillment…

A leading tobacco-industry analyst is forecasting that a majority of Californians will vote in favor of a proposition to ban menthol and other…

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.